Showing posts with label Scott Lobdell. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Scott Lobdell. Show all posts

Monday, April 30, 2012

Comic Review -- Teen Titans #8: A Dark Omen! / Scott Lobdell, Ig Guara, and J.P. Mayer

I'm not familiar with the Ravagers, or why they're being reborn here, but I will admit that this is a pretty cool looking cover.  I'm already missing Brett Booth and Norm Rapmund on the art here, but they deliver a nice assembly shot of the team, and the Tron motif here looks pretty good.  Again, not to familiar with the Ravagers, but everything looks pretty stunning here.

The Titans have been captured by N.O.W.H.E.R.E. and its leader, Harvest.  He has each of them subjected to Omen, a corrupted teen who seems to do some kind of psionic strip-mining of their minds while she manipulates reality around them in a water-filled chamber she calls her "womb."  The Titans begin to lose heart, arguing with one another, as they each become victims of Omen's whims.  Subjected to mental illusions and scenarios that keep them from understanding what is real and what isn't, the Titans are eventually led away by another of Harvest's people, Leash, who tethers them to himself and heads for a place called The Colony.  Harvest also refers to the Titans as his "New Ravagers," implying that they will serves him soon, if they do not already.

Okay, Scott Lobdell.

I'm seriously about an issue from dropping this title.  What started off as a somewhat slow-paced, but fun an promising assembly story has dragged on and on, without any real resolution, into a plodding, we-have-you-now tale that is failing to elicit any real emotion from me, and I suspect plenty of other readers at this point.  Now it's about to divert into a storyline called The Culling, and at this point I couldn't care any less about it.  What happened to the fun and action from the previous issues?

If you're going to drag a story arc on for this long, you have got to keep it interesting and compelling for your readers, and we have proof that this can happen.  Scott Snyder's run on Batman has accomplished that.  This story, not so much.  Oh, the Titans are being held helpless as they wait to be "psionically molested" by Omen?  I just don't care anymore.

This is one of those classic cases of how it's better to show than to tell in comics, and in good writing in general.  It might be more interesting if we got a little more exposition on Omen and what exactly her powers do, or if we actually saw some of these horrible secrets the Titans are having forcibly divulged from their minds.  Instead, we get this uppity girl simply saying, "Ooh, I've shown you all your fears and discovered all your secrets," over and over again.  Yawn.

This arc of the story is not helped by the art, where Brett Booth and Norm Rapmund's absence is immediately noticed.  It's not bad overall, and does a serviceable enough job of maintaining the look established by that team, but in some places things and characters look noticeably stretched and unflattering.  Bunker in particular looks a bit too "off" in this issue, like he's been sculpted from dough.  I'll give it another issue or so to settle into the new look, but so far I'm not terribly impressed with it.

Overall, I can't really recommend this issue for comics readers.  It could be my overall ignorance of DC and Teen Titans characters and lore, but it doesn't seem to really give me much reason to care about Harvest, Omen, N.O.W.H.E.R.E., the Ravagers, or even the Titans' fate at this point.  Add in middling-to-not-memorable artwork, and you've got an issue that really leaves you wanting.  Not recommended.

Fix this, Scott Lobdell.  Or I will take my money to another title.

Tuesday, April 10, 2012

Comic Review -- Teen Titans #7: Assault on Project 13 / Scott Lobdell, Brett Booth, Norm Rapmund

*Sigh*, that damn banner again.  I'll get over it at some point, I swear, but for now, I can't help but sigh in exasperation whenever I see it.  Overall, not a bad cover, though not great, either.  I suppose it's a little confusing.  Superboy looks pained and things look tense with the others moving about, but without knowing who Centerhall is up to this point though, I don't care enough for him to want him on the cover.  Everyone else is barely a blip on the cover, and not that well drawn as you get further back.

In this issue, the Titans learn about Superboy's current fate at the hands of N.O.W.H.E.R.E., and rush off to save him.  Well, more like get dragged off to save him, as Red Robin manages to guilt them into going after they rightly point out that Superboy recently almost killed them all.  We also learn of the existence of Danny the Street, who also apparently escaped from N.O.W.H.E.R.E. with Kid Flash, and who has been working for Red Robin for some time.  It appears he was the one responsible for bringing Kid Flash and Solstice to Red Robin's place a few issues ago.

While the bulk of the team engages N.O.W.H.E.R.E.'s forces, Red Robin is caught by Solstice in the records room of the complex, downloading data on the kids N.O.W.H.E.R.E. has been kidnapping.  When pressed, he tells her he's been building a case against them for a long time, to which she reacts with outrage, claiming that he should have been helping kids like her a long time ago, not waiting for evidence.  While it's never made explicit, the story implies that Red Robin incapacitates her and tries to abandon her at N.O.W.H.E.R.E. by telling the team to leave now.  They won't leave without her though, and they are surprised and overtaken by Harvest, who reveals himself as the man who created N.O.W.H.E.R.E.

I have to admit, at this point I'm starting to get twitchy and want this story to wrap up conclusively.  It's not that it was bad or uninteresting, but it does feel like this arc is starting to drag a bit in places.  Can we please get everyone on the same page?  Can we get a strong idea of the Titans' lineup, headquarters, and so on?  We seem to be so locked in startup mode, and dealing with so many twists and turns in the narrative, that by now I'm starting to feel more than a little weary.

While I can easily see Red Robin having a hidden agenda for the raid on N.O.W.H.E.R.E., I'm having real issues with his implied behavior towards Solstice.  Sure, I think she was overreacting and not seeing the bigger picture, but to suggest he would physically attack her, knock her out, and then leave her where she was last imprisoned... I don't know.  I know Tim has trust issues he needs to overcome, but this seems a touch extreme for the boy who is trying to keep all the superpowered teens together and free from persecution.  I'm eager to see how this is addressed, but it better be damn good, as this issue left a bad taste in my mouth where this part of the story is concerned.

Superboy and Kid Flash have a few amusing exchanges of dialog, as they insult one another during the rescue.  I keep imagining Superboy as sounding like Brandon Routh, and I think more and more I'm hearing Kid Flash as a quick-talking Michael Cera, so it really works on the humor level for me.  I thought their banter in Scott Pilgrim vs. the World was pretty funny.

Artistically, things look as great as ever.  The addition of the NOWHERE villains finally give Brett Booth some more people to draw, even if they aren't developed very well.  Zaniel Templar looks both horrifying and creepy in Wonder Girl's gratuitous and brief solo fight scene with him, and Harvest looks pretty terrifying as well.  I'll be interested to see what he can do next issue.

Overall, while this still makes for an enjoyably continuation of the story, it needs to wrap up soon.  By pushing and extending the arc further and further with more twists and revelations, it's starting to feel less interesting and more exhausting.  I'm willing to keep along for a couple more issues, but unless things get more compelling and less tortuous, I may bow out.  It's a good story, Scott.  It just needs to resolve itself properly.  Recommended.

Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Comic Review -- Teen Titans #5-6 / Scott Lobdell, Brett Booth, & Norm Rapmund

Teen Titans #5: Over Before It's Begun
I think the main reason I enjoy this cover is because Bart is featured wearing the red iteration of the Robin costume while running roughshod around Superboy.  I also like some of the faces he's making while he does it. Amusing, without being too obnoxious.

The Titans take on Superboy... and it doesn't go so well.  Kid Flash gets super-charged on his speed, faster than his body can tolerate, before Wonder Girl kicks him loose.  Bunker gets a few shots in before Superboy uses his own psionic gloves to knock him out. Red Robin actually knocks him down, but wastes time trying to persuade Superboy to change sides, and Superboy knocks him out.  Wonder Girl ropes him, but gets dragged underground to the subway, where the train's impact presumably knocks her out, but not Superboy.  And finally, Solstice tries to reason with him, and nearly gets through to him, before he knocks her out.  Victorious, Superboy is nonetheless confused, and heads back to his N.O.W.H.E.R.E. masters, without Wonder Girl, intending to get some answers from them.

This disastrous first outing, while not unexpected, was well plotted.  It shows how each of the team members think, as well as showing that Superboy, for all his power, is far from invulnerable.  Aside from the physical chinks in his armor, it seems the best weapon any of the Titans had against him was persuasion and the ability to make Superboy doubt his station as a N.O.W.H.E.R.E. agent.  In the end, it actually seems to work, as Superboy returns to them without Wonder Girl, their intended target, or any of the Titans, even.  So, in a way, it was a victory, albeit a moral one as opposed to a tactical one.  Tactically, they get their butts kicked.

I was a little disappointed that Skitter didn't show up at the last second and support her new comrades, but I'm hoping she'll make an appearance in the next issue.

Favorite line of the issue belongs to Wonder Girl: "The bird kid just beat the crap out of the super kid!"

Artistically, things continue to be stellar.  This art style is pretty much exactly what I like in superhero comics,  realistic but slightly cartoony.  I think it makes for a good combination of expressiveness, epic action, and some exaggeration when it's occasionally needed.  The brawl with Superboy itself was well depicted, and Booth consistently turns out good work.

Overall, I think this is a good chapter to what is turning out to be a lengthy intro to the team.  I don't think we'll be wrapping this story up next issue, which is fine, but I do wonder how long this will go on.  With that said, as long as things are kept this interesting, I'll definitely be along for the ride.  Highly recommended.


Teen Titans #6: By the Light...
Fairly epic cover, though it's another "this scene isn't in the story" cover.  Red Robin actually never takes on Grymm, and there's certainly never any danger of the skirmish landing on Kid Flash and Static.  Still, it's a good action shot, and it lends some context to Bart's condition in the aftermath of the Superboy skirmish.

The Titans are starting to limp away from their fight with Superboy, when the N.Y.P.D. try to arrest them.  Skitter shows up and webs them all up, and Kid Flash starts to spark and vibrate violently.  Red Robin takes him to a nearby S.T.A.R. labs office, where Virgil Hawkins, a.k.a. Static, is on duty.  While he works on finding a way to stabilize Kid Flash, Wonder Girl and Bunker square off against another metahuman imprisoned there, named Grymm, who takes over Skitter's mind and tries to use her to escape.  They knock him out, and Virgil uses a prototype suit designed for the Flash to keep Bart stabilized.  It works, and he makes his debut in his new yellow costume, confident and cool.  The team starts talking about a rematch with Superboy, but Red Robin vetoes the idea, saying they need to return to base and prepare for a war.

I'm guessing the character of Jocelyn Lure will be somewhat significant later, especially considering she's apparently some kind of alien (along with Kid Flash), but her appearance is too brief to glean much more than that from her.

The overall story remains interesting, but I wasn't too terribly impressed with the Grymm side-story.  We get almost no explanation of who he is, he repeats key pieces of information unnecessarily and awkwardly, and his existence is never mentioned once Bunker and Wonder Girl get him under control.  I think that story could have been tightened and structured better.

I enjoyed the appearance of Static, who I don't know too much about but have an overall positive opinion of based on the little information I know about him.  I was also amused by Tim's connections to the Justice League, and the fact that he came to Virgil only after trying to get in touch with them.  It makes sense, and furthers the idea that, while Red Robin may be just a kid and not even metahuman, he, like Batman, brings a lot to the table where his team is involved.

Art-wise, I loved Kid Flash's new costume, and the cool debut pose he strikes while wearing it.  Grymm was interesting visually, but odd.  He has a weird mouth line, and apparently never opens his mouth, even though he has plenty of spoken dialog.  I wonder if that was an intentional choice on the part of the artist or writer.  Overall, things continue to look stellar.

Overall, this respite from last issue's high-octane action keeps the character development going, and continues to develop the team's abilities to work together.  I'm curious to see what Red Robin means by preparing for war, but I'm sure it involves dealing with N.O.W.H.E.R.E., and possibly Superboy.  Can't wait to see more of that.  Highly recommended.

Sunday, February 26, 2012

Comic Review -- Teen Titans #3-4 / Scott Lobdell, Brett Booth, & Norm Rapmund

Teen Titans #3: Better to Burn Out... Than to Fade Away
I love how comic book covers can so often be a study in misdirection, if not the perpetual outright lie.  Red Robin and Bunker look great as they clash here, but the closest they come in the story is preparing for fisticuffs... right before Bunker gives Red Robin a great big hug.  They're friends from that point onward.

Kid Flash continues to vacillate between usefulness and idiocy, as he escapes N.O.W.H.E.R.E. custody quickly, with Solstice in tow, but slips and falls off a cliff in the Antarctic, causing her to have to save them.  Wonder Girl impersonates a nurse to intimidate one of the mercenaries from last issue into telling her more about their employers.  And Bunker just happens to run into Red Robin while hopping a train across America, coming across a cocooned Skitter.  They form an alliance, and Red Robin encounters a psionic junk heap called Detritus before having his memory erased of the encounter and being sent back on his way with Skitter and Bunker as if nothing had happened.  I'm sure nothing sinister will come of that.  Finally, as Kid Flash looks up from where he and Solstice fell, he sees a village in the snow, and tries to make for it before it's too late--in vain, the end of the story would suggest.

This was a better section of the story, for me.  While devoid of any real high-octane action, we still have a few significant moments of character developments as the Titans fight each other, bumble rescue attempts, and otherwise find bold ways to get themselves in trouble.  We only see one page worth of Cassie in this issue, but Lobdell makes full use of her appearance, using her hardcase nature and gift for infiltration to make a very believable threat against a man for information.  It makes me eager to see what she'll do with it in the next issue.

I had a similar reaction to Red Robin's incredulity at Bunker's appearance, but at least they were kind enough to lampshade the one-in-a-million possibility with Bunker's response about praying for it to happen.  Based on how his viewpoint was written, I don't think Bunker's some kind of evil N.O.W.H.E.R.E. plant, so I'll take that for what it's worth.  The Detritus skirmish kind of annoyed me, especially with how brief the encounter was.  I can accept that it got the drop on Tim--who doesn't occasionally get surprised and then schooled?--but it seems kind of tacked on or inserted unnecessarily in the story.  Finally, what the heck was a village doing in Antarctica?  Isn't that where Kid Flash and Solstice are?  I hope that gets explained, and quickly, next issue.

I did enjoy Bunker giving Red Robin a big hug when he found out who he was.  Tim was the picture of confusion for a couple of panels there.

Art-wise, I enjoyed Booth's depictions of the Antarctic cliffside, Kid Flash's multi-point escape and rescue of Solstice, and the brief appearance of Detritus.  No real issues with any of it--Booth seems to have gotten away from the occasional nose-lessness of characters that I saw in the last issue.

Overall, this was a good continuation of the story.  The writing was tighter, and the artwork was pretty good.  I'm eager to see the Titans come together, which should happen in the next issue or so.  Onwards and upwards!  Highly recommended.


Teen Titans #4: Danger Squared!
Now this is a fun cover!  Not only is the image of Wonder Girl and Superboy's clash pretty epic in and of itself, but it's making use of a large screen in Times Square to give a more detailed look at the slugfest going on right in front of it.  The art, the storyline suggestion, and the action all made the cover alone make me want to pick up this book.

The Titans--sans Wonder Girl and Superboy--finally all appear at Tim's home in the North Tower Penthouse of Lextower.  Wonder Girl tries pushing her way through a crowd in Times Square as N.O.W.H.E.R.E.--and more specifically, Superboy--track her and instigate a knock-down, drag-out fight.  As Kid Flash and Solstice mysteriously appear at Tim's door, Skitter bemoans her misfortune and the rest of the team gets to know one another.  Finally, footage of the fight between Wonder Girl and Superboy hits the media, and the Titans--minus Skitter--head out to Wonder Girl's aid.

Okay, I'm starting to get a little annoyed with all of the unexplained miracles that keep popping up in this story.  Bunker and Red Robin finding one another was okay, as long as it was that one instance (and was properly lampooned a bit), but now it's getting ridiculous.  What was that village that suddenly appeared to Kid Flash and Solstice in the Antarctic?  Why did it lead to Tim's door--exactly where they needed to go?  The continued occurrence of this kind of deus ex machina is annoying enough, but to not even attempt an explanation is really insulting to your readers.

On the other hand, I really did enjoy the fight between Superboy and Cassie.  The fact that they're attracted to each other didn't have any effect on how hard each fought--clearly the stakes are high for both.  I was a little surprised that nothing was made of the people who must have been in the buildings they demolished, but I can understand how that can be a tertiary concern when you've got two powerhouses intent on beating each other's brains out.  Wonder Girl's use of the lasso to save herself and redirect her flight back into Superboy was really clever.  Clearly this girl's a cunning fighter, even if she may not entirely realize it.

It was impossible for me not to imagine Superboy using Brandon Routh's voice during this story.  Nothing against that actor, but his voice comes off as kind of douchey to me, and Superboy's just such a... well, you know... in this story.

I also really enjoyed Bart's stealing of Tim's clothes.  It was a hilarious running gag, even if only for this issue.  Tim's freaking out and going all Prince Zuko on him was a little over the top for me, though.  There were other ways to show that Tim's a bit of a straight-laced jerk without going to that particular overdramatic place.

Finally... it's good to see the team assembled as they get ready to take on Superboy.  I'm definitely interested to see how this fight goes!

The art here was really good.  I especially liked the visual of Superboy in front of Lex Luthor's image on the big screen... it made him look especially sinister.  The Times Square slugfest was of course a lot of fun to look at as Superboy and Wonder Girl tore into each other.  Finally, the team assembly on the last pages was extremely well drawn.  Bart wearing the red Robin suit made me laugh out loud.

Overall, I'm very pleased with this story.  It provided plenty of action, lots of character development, and the promise of more to come.  Someone had better start explaining those miracle occurrences soon, though, or I'm gonna really lose it.  The artwork is good, the writing is good, and I've got to see how things turn out from this point.  Highly recommended.

Tuesday, February 21, 2012

Comic Review -- Teen Titans #1-2 / Scott Lobdell, Brett Booth, & Norm Rapmund

Okay, a few things before I launch into these reviews.  I'm pretty unfamiliar with the Teen Titans, and mostly picked it up because Tim Drake seems to be leading the charge in this incarnation.  He's always been my favorite Robin, and I have always been curious to check out this team, as they're essentially a junior Justice League, at least at first glance.  There are a bunch of characters here I'm not familiar with, so if my reviews of them come off as uninformed, that's likely because I don't know them very well yet.  Still, I'm really enjoying this series so far, and like its premise.  

With all that said, here we go...

Teen Titans #1: Teen Spirit
Nice cover!  Not really indicative of what's happening in this issue, but it's a nice team shot that looks cool and shows the coming lineup of the team.

The team starts to come together in this issue, amid a crisis of unsettling magnitude.  Super-powered teens are disappearing at an alarming rate, apparent victims of an organization called N.O.W.H.E.R.E.  Tim Drake, also known as Red Robin, monitors several heroes, including Kid Flash, from afar before he's confronted by N.O.W.H.E.R.E.'s agents.  Escaping them, he heads off to find Wonder Girl, who doesn't want anything to do with him at first, but helps him fight off an assault chopper sent by N.O.W.H.E.R.E.  Realizing that Red Robin is becoming a thorn in their side, N.O.W.H.E.R.E. decides to sic its biggest gun on him and his allies: Superboy...

I really like how Tim operates in this issue.  He's like a cross between Ozymandias, with his world-monitoring, and Julius Assange, with his information dumps and willingness to expose sensitive data to the public in the name of his cause.  He's also extremely proactive about finding and recruiting allies, which will serve him well.  Kid Flash annoyed me a bit, but I'm pretty sure that was the intent with his brief appearance.  Wonder Girl was intriguing and cute, but I hope she becomes a little less reactionary and a little more trusting as time goes by.  Overall, the characters were interesting and the action was well paced.  N.O.W.H.E.R.E. seems interesting so far, mostly because I know so little about them right now.  It'll be interesting to see how they're developed.

I enjoyed the art very much.  Brett Booth may not be Jim Lee, but he's not far from the mark in terms of making his characters visually appealing and heroic.  His characters are expressive and his poses for them are realistic, well-positioned, and iconic where they need to be.  Definitely a good fit for superhero comics.  I'll be pleased with the visuals of this story as long as he continues.

Overall, I think this is a promising start to a larger story.  It's much like Justice League, where the team has yet to assemble, but is gradually coming together.  It's beautifully illustrated, and as long as the action is tight and the buildup continues, I'm confident this will be a fun story arc.  Highly recommended.


Teen Titans #2: Underground and Overwhelmed!
Interesting cover.  I'm not familiar with Skitter, but they do a good job of making her look vicious, powerful, and interesting with this one shot.  Of course, you never actually see her web any Titans up in this story.

Kid Flash is stuck in prison, lamenting his superhero decision.  Wonder Girl allows Tim to stay on the couch at her place as thanks for helping her with N.O.W.H.E.R.E.  When he leaves, he sees a story about Skitter, and finds her sister to learn where she is.  He comes into contact with three agents from N.O.W.H.E.R.E.  A fight starts, but when they teleport to Skitter's location, she handily beats them.  She turns on Tim just as he arrives, but Wonder Girl steps in and saves him.  She then tells him she was only paying him back for yesterday, and that she doesn't care about N.O.W.H.E.R.E. and other metahuman teens, and leaves.  Kid Flash escapes from his prison, and finds another captive teen named Solstice, apparently in great pain...

There's a little bit of downtime for the heroes to catch their breaths before the action resumes, and it's well-spent on character development.  The brief insights into Kid Flash and Superboy were good, though it would have been better to give them something to do, however briefly.  Tim continues hunting for super-teens and analyzing N.O.W.H.E.R.E., and Cassie makes a slight effort to get him to open up to her.  The fight scenes are okay, but I was more impressed with the dialog, particularly Tim's response to Templar still being alive after the last issue.

Skitter was viciously impressive, but had little role in this story once Wonder Girl trounced her.  I was a little confused that she seemed to dispatch three guys in little to no time, but gets laid out by one punch from Wonder Girl.  Tim's immediate reaction to Wonder Girl's sudden intervention was amusing, though I'm skeptical of it leading anywhere.  Cassie doesn't seem like she's attracted to him, at least not yet.

Oh, and when Kid Flash busted out of captivity, I found myself asking how long it would be before he messed up and got captured again.  Hopefully I'm wrong, but based on what little I've seen of him so far, I couldn't help thinking it.

One minor issue I have with Brett Booth's art in this issue is noses.  I know they're hard to draw head-on, but in some places his characters look like they simply don't have one, or have an afterthought of one, and it distracts me.  It's a rare occurrence, but I did notice it a couple times in this issue.  Very horrifically impressive drawing of Skitter for her brief appearance.  I'll be interested to see more of how she's portrayed in future issues.

Overall, I wasn't as impressed as I was with the previous issue.  It felt a bit slow in places, though the lull scenes were well-handled.  I think the writing could have been a little tighter, and the characters just didn't pop with as much personality as in the last comic.  Still, the story is progressing, and I want to see how things turn out.  Recommended.